110 W. New York Ave.
DeLand, FL 32720
386-734-4622
posted Nov 8, 2012 - 8:43:23am
A referendum asking Volusians to tax themselves more to help schools failed at the polls Nov. 6, by just 944 votes out of 206,618 ballots cast.
Facing a $25 million deficit, the Volusia County School Board asked residents to vote for an extra mill of property taxes — $1 for every $1,000 of property value.
The first year, the new tax would have pulled in $26 million, enough to offset a decline in state revenues and close the school system’s budget gap without laying off teachers.
Cliff Martin, an Ormond Beach voter, was happy with the election results.
“I got my tax bill Nov. 1, and I opened it, and the school tax was better than 50 percent of the tax bill,” he said. “I can’t believe the arrogance of these people. We all need money.”
Volusia Tax Reform Executive Director Margie Patchett had been vocal in opposition to the additional tax. She was very happy with the results.
“The people have spoken; they just can’t handle any more tax increases,” Patchett said. “They believe the school district needs to do the same thing as the private sector.”
Patchett said the private sector has had to make deep cuts in recent years, including cuts in payroll and benefits.
Volusia County School Board members have warned that without the extra funding, arts and sports will face the deepest cuts.
Patchett said she hopes, if that happens, parents will make up the difference by working more closely with the schools.
“We want the best education for our children,” she said. “Certainly the arts are important. But the money should be spent in the classroom with the teachers.”
Volusia Tax Reform, she said, believes the district’s biggest problem is administrative bloat, and unfair funding by the state.
Patchett said Volusia Tax Reform would be glad to help the School Board lobby Tallahassee to change the way money is divided among school districts.
Currently, of every $1 of state money appropriated for schools by the Florida Legislature, Volusia County receives 96.1 cents, because of a complicated formula that considers the incomes and assets of Florida’s 67 counties.
If Volusia received the full dollar, perhaps no new taxes would be needed, Patchett said.
“The property tax is not the way to go,” she said. “Bad economy. Bad idea.”
School Board Member Candace Lankford said the local board has lobbied Tallahassee for more equal funding since 2004.
They haven’t stopped lobbying, but fixing the differential isn’t the sole answer, and it’s not going to help the immediate deficit, Lankford said.
“We took it to the Supreme Court in 2005-06,” Lankford said. “We have been working for Volusia to get a more fair share of funding.”
Lankford noted the school referendum lost by less than 1 percent of the vote.
“It’s heartbreaking,” Lankford said. “And I think it’s very shortsighted to not see the real value of education.”
The Volusia County School Board will begin immediate budget workshops to find ways to cut from its 2013-14 budget.
“We filled the gaps last year with nonrecurring money,” Lankford said.
She has been advocating passage of the referendum, speaking to local governments, civic groups, and other members of the public, for three months, warning them of the realities of additional budget cuts.
“There is a list of things we are going to have to consider as potential cuts,” Lankford said.
To see the list, visit www.myvolusiaschools.org/1mill.
Reader Comments
The comments posted below are posted by readers, not by The Beacon staff. These comments express the views and opinions of the authors, and not the administrators, moderators or webmaster. The comments forum is governed by these rules. Please use the report abuse link if you find offensive comments.
ONE WHOLE WEEK FOR NARC ON THEIR PARENTS FOR CAFFEINE AND TOBACCO???
INSTEAD OF A ONE WEEK MATH CAMP ALL THEIR LIVES
NO YOU STARTED GETTING INTO AREAS THAT COMMIES GET INTO, NOT TEACHERS................OUR PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE DOING JUST FINE, THEY WILL GROW AND YOU UNION HACKS ARE DONE.......the unions killed it..............not the poor voter..........look in the mirror boys.........
AFTER BEATING US FOR ASKING THEM TO PAY A SMALL 3% OF THEIR 'OWN' RETIREMENT, THEY SUED US WITH 'OUR OWN MONEY' AND THEN WON..........
HEY BOYS WELCOME TO BARRY HUSSEIN'S PARTY. THE RICH ARE LEAVING....THEY ARE CASHING OUT AND GETTING OUT OF DODGE.........
YOU BOYS GOT REAL ENVIOUS AND JEALOUS OF THE PRODUCERS........NOT REALIZING THEY PAID 'YOUR CHECKS FOR LIFE'.................
YOU IGNORED 400,000 AMERICANS FILING FIRST TIME UNEMPLOYMENT EVERY THURSDAY MORNING - THOSE WERE TAXPAYERS GUYS!!!!!
YOU IGNORED 60 MINUTES TELLING YOU THAT OUR KIDS WERE LIVING IN CARS.......................
YOU IGNORED BREVARD, SEMINOLE AND FLAGLER ALL SHUTTING DOWN SCHOOLS................YOU WERE GOING TO STEAL MORE OF 'OUR MONEY'.....................
NO MO MONEY GUYS...........FACE IT............
YOU ARE NOW IN THE JOB BLEEDOUT THAT AMERICA HAS BEEN GOING THRU FOR 4 YEARS...........THAT YOU IGNORED..........
THERE ARE 400,000 AMERICANS QUALIFIED TO WORK 180 DAYS A YEAR, FOR 6 HOURS A DAY--READY TO WORK EVERY SINGLE THURSDAY
.AND THEY WILL DO THAT WORK FOR 25,000 AND 'NO RETIREMENT' LIKE IT IS DONE IN THE 'REAL WORLD'................
AND TEACHERS, YOU DON'T THINK YOU WERE GOING TO WIN OVER THE COPS AND FIREMEN, DO YOU?????
IF YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE WORD SOCIALIST MEANS - THANK A UNION TEACHER..............
ELECTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES AND YOU BOYS HAVE LOVED ILLEGAL ALIENS IN EVERY CLASS BECAUSE IT WAS 'TEACHER JOB SECURITY'......................
FOR ALL THESE DECADES YOU LOVED THE DESTRUCTION.....................YOU DIDN'T CARE THAT WE WERE ALL PAYING THEIR 'FREE FREIGHT'..............
IT USED TO BE ABOUT THE KIDS BUT YOUR UNIONS DUES TOOK PREFERENCE OVER OUR BUSSES,
AND 'OUR KIDS ARE GETTING KILLED WALKING HOME' AND YOU BOYS DIDN'T CARE.................NOW WE DON'T CARE.............
BESIDES YOU ARE GRADUATING IDIOTS AND DUMBING DOWN THE SCORES?????
YOU GUYS HAVE TO JOIN THE EMPLOYEE DESTRUCTION THAT BARRY HAS BEEN FORCING ON THE REST OF AMERICA FOR 4 YEARS..........
WELCOME TO THE PARTY, BRING SOME SNACKS, THERE ARE ABOUT 40 MILLION OF US OUT HERE................AND IT WAS SO ARROGANT AND IGNORANT TO THINK YOU WOULD CONTINUE TO STEAL FROM US FOR YOUR 'CHECKS FOR LIFE'..............
In his great first essay, Parkinson displayed his fundamental method: He reasoned from the behavior of individuals--the different times a busy man and "an elderly lady of leisure" might take to write a postcard--to the behavior of organizations, in this instance their inexorable tendency to grow regardless of the amount of work to be done. Two axioms governed the process, he noted: "(1) an official wants to multiply subordinates, not rivals; and (2) officials make work for each other"--supervising each other's efforts, holding meetings and so on.
He noted that:
Work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion.
Expenditure rises to meet income.
Expansion means complexity, and complexity decay.
THE LAW OF DELAY: Delay is the deadliest form of denial.
THE LAW OF TRIVIALITY: The time spent on any item of a committee's agenda will be in inverse proportion to the sum of money involved.
School Board Member Candace Lankford defended Dr. Smith’s compensation package, noting she is doing more. “The superintendent’s staff has been reduced from 18 to 13,” Lankford said.
Let's take a look now, shall we?
http://myvolusiaschools.org/superintendent/Pages/Superintendents-Staff.aspx
There are 16 on her staff now. Using Lankford's own reasoning, we should expect that Margaret Smith's pay has went down accordingly.. correct?
Let's look at the wages from the staff members that were listed in 2009 in the DeLand Beacon news story, and who also show up in the 2010 public salary database.
Robert Moll, financial and business services, $126,711 per year 2009.
Robert Moll, financial and business services, $128,608 per year 2010.
Peromnia Grant, assistant superintendent for personnel services, $117,205 per year 2009.
Peromnia Grant, assistant superintendent for personnel services, $117,955 per year 2010.
Nancy Wait, director of community information, $67,561 per year 2009.
Nancy Wait, director of community information, $70,264 per year 2010.
Allene Dupont, director of K-12 curriculum and SIP services, $92,520 per year 2009.
Allene Dupont, director of K-12 curriculum and SIP services, $93,907 per year 2010.
Barbara Bush, director of exceptional student education, $96,048 per year 2009.
Barbara Bush, director of exceptional student education, $110,897 per year 2010.
And finally:
Margaret Smith, Superintendent $172,607 per year 2009
Margaret Smith, Superintendent $179,465 per year 2010.
Now let's look at some of the titles and salaries of the people in the School Board's "Technology Services" department. These salaries are from the 2010 salary database. The 2012 salaries are surely higher.
$56,674.48 Barnes, Patti Lynn – Acct Analyst,Telecommunication
$70,619.48 Bridges, Janna C – Manager, Computer Operations
$30,920.52 Brothers, Doada C – Assistant Shift Leader
$50,505.00 Dunn, Frankie M – Network Engineer II
$81,102.44 Engel, Judith A – Manager, Software Applications
$55,237.52 Finnegan, Thomas Patrick – Network Engineer II
$50,803.78 Hendrickson, Darlene E – Information Systems Analyst
$75,713.56 Kilpatrick, James G Senior Systems Engineer
$74,895.48 Marple, Stephen E Manager, Network Engineering
$58,670.13 Rushworth Jr., Robert J Senior Computer Oper Spec
$37,800.52 Brett, Brenda Admin Secretary, MIS
$74,220.52 Steele, William Burdette Senior Systems Engineer
$62,700.00 Sylvia, Alison Quimby Senior Information Sys Analyst
$51,153.46 O’Brien, Jan Turner Specialist, Budget
$67,862.08 Willis, Lynn Senior Network Security Engin
$78,825.56 Woodward, Daniel P Senior Information Sys Analyst
$38,165.56 Bennett, Barbara Ellen Specialist, Security Admin
$61,464.52 Testerman, Harold D Systems Engineer III
$36,189.72 Miller, Susan R Technician
$81,102.44 Bateman, Richard J Manager, Software Applications
$48,561.43 Erwin, Danny Wayne Network Engineer I
$45,269.08 Bray, Rosemary Computer Programmer III
$55,876.52 Lind, David E Systems Engineer II
$43,686.92 Hester, Elizabeth E Senior Security Adm Specialist
$26,660.10 Kennedy, Jennifer E Computer Technician
$68,573.56 Houde, Joseph E Systems Engineer III
$41,982.52 Cudlin, Robin Marie Senior Network Technician
$48,054.00 Holloway, Myrna A Computer Programmer III
$35,326.22 Horn, Douglas S Analyst, Forms And Reports
$30,654.23 Pla, Concepcion A Office Specialist II
$69,923.70 Delio, Audrey A Senior Information Sys Analyst
$38,169.44 Leon, James Specialist, Computer Operation
$37,773.94 Hinckley, Lianmei Computer Programmer
$38,149.93 Clayton, Michael Brian Computer Programmer
$36,939.06 Tsai, Mao-Chen Computer Programmer
$45,443.37 Donohue, Karen S Network Engineer I
$38,165.56 Rodenbaugh Jr, Hubert Earl User Support Analyst II
$41,138.68 Ayala, Carlos M Network Engineer I
$47,769.24 Erker, Jim W Computer Programmer
$65,128.25 Richmond, Kenneth D Manager, Systems Engineering
$64,573.50 Aten, Mitchell W Senior Information Sys Analyst
$54,646.72 Willingham, Pamela A Information Systems Analyst
$37,398.63 Williams, Lawanna C Computer Programmer
$21,750.86 Colon, Lisa M Office Specialist II
$28,886.96 Rodriguez, Priscilla E Office Specialist II
$44,373.58 Vaught, William R User Support Analyst II
$33,997.56 Turley, Tracy J Technician, Network
$36,244.10 Hilton, Matthew A Systems Engineer I
$29,570.23 Smith-Crawford, Aaron Technician, Network
$50,725.46 Venkataramani, Kalpana Senior Information Sys Analyst
$35,614.02 Risley, Jay Michael Specialist, Computer Operation
$34,696.48 Foley, Scott James Analyst, User Support
$88,937.37 Hoag, Jennifer J Assistant Director, Reptng Req
$76,125.10 Boulware, Donald P Executive Director, MIS
$67,004.73 Lacey, Bonnie D Analyst, FTE Data
$65,128.25 Leary, Mark Manager, Software Applications (promoted to Asst Director since published)
$84,931.42 Parsons, Keith T Asst Director, Application Sys
$71,641.06 Kennedy, Alex J Asst Dir, Operational Services
$42,383.87 Dykstra, Paula B User Support Analyst II
$41,155.56 Anastario, Carol Senior User Support Analyst
$37,757.45 Vanarsdall, Marianne D User Support Analyst II
$46,039.01 Kaloostian, Gina M Specialist, Student Accounting
$53,840.44 Whitaker, Mark C Senior Computer Technician
$48,240.49 Boudreau, Richard Allan Technician, Media Production
Wages unknown:
McDaniel, Emily - Web Developer
Levene, Jessica - Manager, Lrn Tech & Help Desk
Ackerman, Charles - Specialist, Learning Technology
Goodman, Chad - Technician, Media Production
Orzel, Jerry - Technician, Media Production
This list does not include everyone.
This is Parkinson's Law exemplified: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinsons_law
PS: My kid is in second grade (after dark at his last school in Deland, we were actually afraid to park outside of school grounds!!).
I grew up in Seminole County and although some of the best government schools in the state, they are still inferior to a quality private school education. The people of Seminole chose to invest in schools that are performing well not throwing money into the school system with zero return. I shudder at the thought of having to send my child to Deland High School.
My property tax bill is criminal, the school board get's enough money, so do the "unfortunate poor" via the Hospital Authority (let's abolish this, nobody is paying for my healthcare!).
This county is mired in liberal, government employee largesse with poor results, bloated government and unfair taxation.
Elementary school is like daycare for my kid. I have to teach him so he actually learns something...there is zero challenge as they teach to the lowest common denominator. My kid reads at a near 4th grade level and 3rd grade in math because of his and my hardwork OUTSIDE of school.
Let the School Board eat cake!
FIRE MARGARET SMITH.
The new budget is based on a proposed property-tax rate of 7.888 mills, or about $7.89 per $1,000 of taxable value. The tentative rate for 2012-13 is less than last year’s 8.06 mills, and also below the rollback rate of 8.2131 mills. The rollback rate is the rate that would generate property-tax revenues equal to those of the year before.
If adopted at the School Board’s final budget meeting Sept. 11, the 7.888-mill rate will cost the average Volusia County homeowner $619, less than last year’s $650 tax bite. The decrease in the tax rate and the anticipated revenue track the continuing decline of property values.
So why did the school board lower taxes and then ask then lobby for the referendum? This makes no sense.
Vastly inferior Volusia County schools? Check FCAT scores of public schools vs charters and VCS scores are way better. How are the FCAT scores at your private school? What? They don't take FCAT? If the teachers were any good, they'd welcome FCAT scores for comparison, wouldn't they? Think of what you could be doing with all of that money you are wasting!
While we were making "bank" this teacher was making lousy money and then spending some of it paying for classroom supplies the school doesn't see fit to provide!
I guess that meeting YOU had yesterday was scheduled and run by YOU.
And I guess when YOU worked for the VP of a very large software company, the largest of its kind YOU were the one that set up the meetings and were responsible for its existance.
And I'm sure, since YOU were the boss of the 3rd largest food service in the world, YOU were the one that created best in class problem resolution team.
You can consider yourself very lucky to have been employed by so many "progressive" and foward thinking companies. However I don't think that Floridas school systems would fall into that category.
So my point is that she's one person in a really big "pond"! And I guess she may not be as impressive as you to run things her way!!
In the end you sound like so many disgruntled union hating unhappy voters out there this week.
BTW I work for the largest telecom company in the world, now who's impressive? or at least impressed with themselves
How long have you been teaching?
What does "at least we got something" mean?
You voted not to maintain funding for our children, because YOU think they only need to be taught reading, writing, and math? Your outlook on education is FRIGHTENING and I feel badly for the children that are entrusted to your care each day.
I agree that an additional sales tax referendum would have been a good option to consider, but do you think that would have passed? I doubt it. For me it came down to this decision: Pay more out of my pocket to invest in educating the students in our county, or vote no and watch our schools and our childrev suffer the consequences.
As far as being "fair"...my property taxes were $6,000 5 years ago and now they are $4,000. Our property owners are paying LESS now and our school system is suffering. I don't mind paying a few hundred a year more, because I fel like investing in education should be a priority. Narrow minded voters did not realize that that it would have helped their property value in the long run! (Do you really think the Chamber of Commerce would have supported a tax increase without understanding the long term payoff?)
You want to talk about UNfair....For every dollar Volusia County sends to Tallahassee, when legislators return it for education funding we get back about 96 cents. They take 4% of it and give it to other counties.
Reading over these ignorant posts reinforces my belief that most of the voters in Seminole County are indeed smarter than our uniformed voters.
To Sensible Citizens: The voters of Seminole County are not 'smarter' than the voters of Volusia County. The FUNDAMENTAL issue with the referendum is NOT whether the schools need these additional funds or whether the schools could be better stewards of the monies they have today. The FUNDAMENTAL issue is WHY does the burden for this extra funding fall ONLY on the property owner. You stated 'the voters of Volusia County don't want to pay for it'. YOu see the referendum presented did not ask ALL Volusia County citizens to pay for it - it only asked property owners to fund it. I agree education is key to our future BUT the plate for the additional funds should be passed to EVERYONE - not just the property owners. Our new favorite word is 'FAIR' - requiring EVERYONE to pay their fair share to get good education would be the appropriate route to go. If an additional sales tax referendum, for example, had been presented it most likely would have passed.
Thugs who don't want to be there but are required to be, prostitots running around in hootchy shorts, the hallways filled with language you wouldn't hear in most bars, too many administrators and sadly, yes, teachers who couldn't give a d@mn less.
It galls me to no end that I still have to fund the mostly **** education the other children in this county are subjected to and if there parents don't care then I sure as hel l don't either. I am SOOO glad it went down in flames.
I say,"More education for the money, not more money for education".
Also, if the school system had all the money in the world, they would still gripe.
One more thing, I AM PRO CHOICD on alternative ways of teaching kids. If Florida Virtual works, great. If homeschooling works, I am fine with that. Many times I have had to teach my kids extra because the school system has dropped the ball.
The ignorant comments on here trying to blame the teacher's union, show how uninformed our voters were. The Daytona Beach Chamber of Commerce and Daytona Speedway were in favor of the school board referendum, because they understand the value in have great schools.
In the end, our children and our community are the losers because of voter ignorance. Every one claims they want great schools, but the citizens of Volusia County don't want to pay for it.
Once again I feel I must correct the teacher, it is RESEARCH not RE SEARCH.
Hopefully you are not one of my children's teachers.....
Terry - We just had a meeting yesterday. We had all members of our team on a conference call discussing things that work and things that don't work as well as ways to make the processes of our jobs go smoother.
Our union.... oh, wait we don't have a union so we can sit down with our bosses and discuss things like that. We do, on a regular basis. I'm sorry if you don't have a job like that, go find one.
My job before that I worked for the VP of the company and we regularly sat down and discussed the good and bad of the job. (By the way, that was a $1.2 billion a year software company, the largest of it's kind in the world.)
My job before that one, I was the boss and I regularly sat down with my employees and discussed the good and bad of the job. (By the way, at the time, that was the 3rd largest food service organization in the world.)
Thirty-two years in the workforce and I have always been able to speak my mind, good or bad.
What exactly is your point????
I'm not sure you understand what a union does, or what a union member is. I have one word for you re search. LOL
Let me ask you a question, ever see something at work that could be done better? Ever hear your boss make a bad decision?
What did you do?
Wasn't it "YOUR" job? Wasn't it "YOUR" boss?
See not so fun or sensible is it?
and
"I am a teacher, a union member"
So how come YOUR union keeps telling us that the schools need more money?
Doesn't YOUR union know what is going on in the schools?
Do you as teachers and dues paying union members not tell YOUR union that they should be getting the school system to stop wasting money rather than wasting YOUR union dues on things like advertising for more taxes????
What are YOU doing to get YOUR union to get the school system to stop wasting?
It is YOUR union, are there not enough people that think like you to do anything about it?
If there aren't then "John" isn't really stereotyping, is he?
Seems to me you should be looking at yourselves and your union.
Oh, and it is "firsthand" or "first-hand", not "first hand". Just saying, for a teacher you're not nearly as smart .....
I know more and more parents using FLVS due to the sorry state of the school system here. I totally support it and have used it it is excellent and you can monitor your children's learning and progress. I was really amazed that my daughter could not form a decent paragraph until I had home schooled her. What a scary thought.
I am a teacher, a union member, and a democrat, and I voted no on this. You are not nearly as smart and well versed on this subject as you think you are.
Comment on this article
Commenting is closed for this article.
If you would like to contribute a letter to the editor, please click here.
Did you find this story interesting or informative? Subscribe to The West Volusia Beacon to read more stories by Jen Horton and Al Everson, along with others from our award-winning writers. Subscribe now!
Photos - Real Estate - Newcomer's Guide - Beacon Magazines - Advertise - Local Web Sites - About Us - Beacon Archives